Refillable vs Closed Pod Systems: Which Fits Your Brand?

· CigGo — Shenzhen Dorteam Technology Co., Ltd.

The choice is a business model, not a spec sheet

Refillable and closed pod systems often look interchangeable in a catalogue. Both are small rechargeable devices that take a pod, both use ceramic coils, and both are assembled on the same kind of line. The difference that matters is where the repeat revenue comes from — and that decision drives nearly everything else: pod capacity, fill method, packaging, compliance path, and even how much support your channel needs.

This guide is written for brand owners and buyers comparing the two routes. It avoids claiming that one architecture is "better"; the right answer depends on what you sell and which market you sell it in. At the end there is a decision table and the CigGo platforms that correspond to each model.

What "refillable" and "closed" actually mean

A closed pod system ships with pods that are prefilled and sealed at the factory. The user replaces the pod when it runs out; they never open it, never fill it, and never choose a bottle of e-liquid. The device is rechargeable, and the pod is the consumable.

A refillable pod system (also called an open pod system) ships with an empty or fillable pod. The user adds their own liquid through a fill port, and replaces the pod when the coil wears out. The device is rechargeable, the pod is a consumable, and the liquid is a separate consumable that the user — or your brand — supplies.

The two categories are sometimes confused with disposable vapes, which are sealed devices where battery, coil and liquid are discarded together. A pod system, by contrast, keeps the battery and replaces the pod. That distinction alone changes the economics of the product.

Closed pod Refillable (open) pod
Who fills the pod Factory User or brand
What the customer buys repeatedly Prefilled pods Empty pods + liquid
Consistency Very high — sealed at the factory Depends on fill quality and liquid
Brand control over flavour Complete Shared with the customer
Typical pod capacity (CigGo platforms) 1.8–2.0 ml 1.8–2.5 ml
Compliance story Sealed consumer product Device plus separate liquid
Best fit Brands selling finished SKUs Liquid brands and enthusiast channels

Where the money comes from

The single most important difference is the revenue curve.

With a closed model, the device is a one-off purchase and the pods are the annuity. Your customer returns to the same SKU for pods, so the pod supply chain — not the device — is what retains them. This suits brands that want a predictable, barcode-able retail product and a simple story for distributors: one device, a small flavour range, a replenishment order every few weeks.

With a refillable model, the device is a one-off purchase, the pod is a lower-frequency consumable, and the liquid is the real annuity. This suits liquid brands, because the customer is already buying bottles; the pod device becomes the hardware that delivers their existing product line. It also suits markets where a pod capacity cap makes prefilled format less attractive, because the user can top up rather than rely on factory fill volume.

The practical consequence is that a closed line needs you to manage pod inventory across flavours, while a refillable line needs you to manage liquid compatibility, fill instructions and coil wear. Neither is simpler; they are different operations.

The customer experience, and the failure modes

Closed pods win on convenience: no filling, no mess, no wrong-liquid decisions, and performance is consistent from pod to pod because filling and sealing happened under factory QC. The failure modes are mostly supply-side — a flavour going out of stock, or a pod that does not seat cleanly on the device.

Refillable pods win on control: the user can choose any compatible liquid, refill when they want, and replace the pod without replacing the device. The failure modes are user-side — overfilling, filling with the wrong viscosity, leaving a pod half-full for weeks, or a coil that wears faster than expected. That is why refillable hardware lives or dies on the fill port design, the seal, and clear instructions.

For a B2B buyer, this is a service question, not just a product question. If your channel cannot support customers through a filling routine, closed pods remove a whole class of complaints. If your channel is a vape shop that already advises on liquids, refillable pods turn that advice into hardware sales.

Compliance and market fit

Regulatory ceilings decide which architecture is practical in a given market. In TPD-style markets, the pod capacity is capped at 2 ml and nicotine strength at 20 mg/ml, and the product must be child-resistant and tamper-evident. Both architectures can meet that cap, but the arithmetic differs: a closed pod must deliver a satisfying session inside 2 ml of factory fill, while a refillable pod lets the user top up the same 2 ml chamber.

In markets without a 2 ml cap, larger refillable pods and higher-capacity closed pods become viable. The engineering question then shifts from "how do we fit the regulation" to "how do we keep leakage and coil life under control at this volume".

Compliance is also about documentation. Closed pods carry the fill, flavour and batch record inside the pod; refillable systems separate device and liquid, which can simplify some labelling questions and complicate others (for example, which party is responsible for the liquid's notification). Buyers should confirm the split with their importer before committing to either route.

What it means for the factory

On the manufacturing side, the two models use overlapping hardware but different processes. A closed line needs filling and sealing capacity, flavour changeover control, and batch traceability at pod level. A refillable line needs fill-port tooling, seal testing, and often a wider pod resistance range so the same device can serve different liquids.

Both need the same fundamentals: incoming material control, coil and pod leak testing, outgoing AQL inspection, and a warranty position on manufacturing defects. The difference shows up in MOQ and tooling. Closed pods usually require flavour-level MOQs because filling is a batch process; refillable pods can be ordered empty, which makes mixed-model trial orders easier.

It is common for a brand to start with one architecture, test it in a single market, and add the other later from the same platform. That is easier when the device platform is shared — the same battery and shell can often accept either pod type, which reduces tooling and packaging work.

A decision table for buyers

If this is true Choose
You sell a finished retail SKU and want one barcode per flavour Closed pod
You own a liquid line and want the device to deliver it Refillable pod
Your market caps pods at 2 ml and you want top-up flexibility Refillable pod
Your channel cannot support customers through refilling Closed pod
You want the widest flavour control with no filling operation Closed pod
You want a lower-fill-frequency consumable and hardware upsell Refillable pod
You are testing a market with a small first order Refillable pod (empty pods, mixed models)
You need pod-level batch traceability for a large retail programme Closed pod

The CigGo platforms for each route

CigGo builds both architectures on the M-series pod platform. On the refillable side, the M22 Refillable Pod System uses 1.8 ml food-grade PCTG pods with a ceramic 1.0 Ω coil, and is available with empty pods or factory-prefilled pods — useful when a brand wants to test both models from one device. The Bysoul M23 open pod system takes a 2.5 ml refillable pod with 0.8 Ω or 0.6 Ω coil options, aimed at buyers who want a larger open pod for markets without a 2 ml cap. The M37 Bysoul is the enthusiast end: 23 W output, 750 mAh, a 0.42″ OLED, adjustable airflow and a leak-resistant refillable cartridge.

On the closed side, the M20 closed pod system runs 1.8 ml prefilled pods at 0.6 Ω, the M21 runs 2.0 ml pods and adds a vibration cue when the pod connects, and the M28 Bysoul-ii runs 1.8 ml pods at 0.5 Ω. All three share the same 450 mAh rechargeable device platform and Type-C charging. The full family is listed on the pod system hub.

If you are still defining the product, the earlier guide on what a pod vape is and how closed and refillable systems differ covers the terminology, and the OEM checklist in how to choose a pod system for OEM/ODM walks through the specification decisions.

Samples and the first order

The fastest way to settle the refillable-versus-closed question is to run both through your own flavour line before committing tooling. Ask for a device sample plus empty and prefilled pods, fill one pod yourself, and compare leak behaviour, coil life and the first-puff experience. A week of testing usually reveals more than a specification sheet.

Standard MOQ on CigGo pod systems is 500 pcs per model and negotiable for first orders; samples ship in 1–3 working days, bulk orders in 7–15 working days, and OEM orders in 10–25 days after sample confirmation. Devices carry a 3–6 month warranty against manufacturing defects, and every unit is assembled under an ISO 13485:2016-certified quality management system in the 6,000 m² dust-free Shenzhen workshop.

Frequently asked questions

Is a refillable pod cheaper for the customer than a closed pod?

Usually yes over time, because the user buys liquid rather than prefilled pods, and replaces the pod less often than a closed-pod user replaces a sealed pod. The device cost is similar. The trade-off is filling effort and the risk of user error.

Can one device take both a closed and a refillable pod?

Sometimes — it depends on the platform. The CigGo M22 platform has both prefilled and empty pod options, so a brand can run both models from one device shell. Other platforms are dedicated to one architecture. Confirm pod compatibility before mixing.

Does refillable mean a lower MOQ?

It can, because empty pods can be ordered without a flavour batch. That makes mixed-model trial orders easier than closed pods, which are filled in flavour batches. The device MOQ still applies per model.

Which system suits TPD markets better?

Both can comply, but refillable pods are often preferred in 2 ml markets because the user can top up the same capped chamber. Closed pods must deliver the whole session inside the 2 ml fill. The right answer depends on your flavour line and channel support.

Can you supply prefilled pods for a refillable platform?

Yes. The M22 Refillable platform supports both empty and factory-prefilled pods, so a brand can test a sealed-pod model and an open-pod model from the same device. Filling is quoted separately from the hardware.

Next step

Send your target market, expected annual volume and whether your channel already sells liquid through the inquiry form — sales replies with FOB pricing and a pod specification proposal within one business day.